best advocate in delhi

STAGES OF A WRIT PETITION (HIGH COURT / SUPREME COURT

Preparation & Legal Grounds

Summary:

The petitioner must identify which fundamental or legal right is violated. Proper documents, affidavits, and annexures are prepared.

Example:

A government officer is transferred as punishment without reason → violation of Article 14.

Judgment:

D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997) → Court stressed that violation of fundamental rights justifies writ jurisdiction.


2️. Filing of the Writ Petition

Summary:

Petition is filed along with index, synopsis, affidavit, vakalatnama, annexures, and court fees.

Example:

Writ of Mandamus seeking direction to police to register FIR.

Judgment:

Lalita Kumari v. State of U.P. (2013) → Mandatory registration of FIR for cognizable offence.


3️. Admission / Preliminary Hearing

Summary:

Court checks whether the petition has merit and falls under writ jurisdiction.

Court may:

  • Issue Notice
  • Dismiss the petition
  • Give interim relief

Example:

High Court stays demolition notice on first hearing.

Judgment:

State of Uttar Pradesh v. Visheshwar (1995) → Admission stage is for prima-facie assessment.


4️. Issue of Notice to Respondents

Summary:

Court sends notice to government department/authority to file their reply.

Example:

Municipal Corporation is asked to explain illegal sealing order.

Judgment:

A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India (1969) → Principles of natural justice mandatory.


5️. Filing of Counter-Affidavit by Respondents

Summary:

Government department explains its actions with records.

Example:

Police files reply showing reasons for inaction or delay.

Judgment:

Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) → Government must justify actions affecting personal liberty.


6️. Filing of Rejoinder by Petitioner

Summary:

Petitioner rebuts the government’s reply and clarifies facts.

Example:

Petitioner denies allegations about incomplete documents.

Judgment:

S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981) → Transparency & counter replies essential for fair hearing.


7️. Final Arguments

Summary:

Both sides argue law, judgments, rights violations, and factual issues.

Example:

Petitioner argues that the transfer order is mala fide and violates Article 14.

Judgment:

R.D. Shetty v. International Airport Authority (1979) → Administrative actions must be fair and non-arbitrary.


8️. Final Order / Judgment

Summary:

Court passes final orders:

  • Allow the petition
  • Dismiss it
  • Give directions
  • Order compensation
  • Transfer case to another authority

Example:

HC directs the university to declare withheld exam results within 7 days.

Judgment:

Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa (1993) → Compensation for violation of fundamental rights.


9️. Review / Appeal (If applicable)

Summary:

Aggrieved party can file:

  • Review Petition – same court
  • SLP (Special Leave Petition) – Supreme Court under Article 136

Judgment:

P. Nalla Thampy Thera v. Union of India (1983) → Review permissible only on error apparent on record.


Summary Chart

StageWhat HappensExampleLandmark Case
1. GroundsRights violation identifiedIllegal transferD.K. Basu
2. FilingPetition filed with documentsMandamus for FIRLalita Kumari
3. AdmissionCourt checks meritInterim stayVisheshwar
4. NoticeGovt notifiedSealing caseA.K. Kraipak
5. CounterGovt replyPolice explains delayManeka Gandhi
6. RejoinderPetitioner rebutsDenial of allegationsS.P. Gupta
7. ArgumentsFinal hearingArbitrary actionR.D. Shetty
8. JudgmentFinal orderExam resultsNilabati Behera
9. Review/SLPAppealErrorNalla Thampy
Tags: No tags

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *