An accused person can file an application for discharge under the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973 in India when they believe there is insufficient evidence or legal grounds for their prosecution. The procedure and relevant sections of the CrPC depend on whether the case is being tried in a Magistrate’s Court or a Sessions Court. Here’s a step-by-step explanation:
1. When to File for Discharge
An application for discharge can be filed at the stage when the court is considering whether there is enough evidence to frame charges against the accused. This stage arises after the completion of the investigation and filing of the charge sheet, but before charges are formally framed.
2. Legal Provisions for Discharge
- Sessions Trial (Under Chapter XVIII of CrPC):
Section 227 of the CrPC allows the accused to apply for discharge if the judge finds that no sufficient ground exists to proceed with the trial. - Trial of Warrant Cases by Magistrates (Under Chapter XIX of CrPC):
Section 239 permits the Magistrate to discharge the accused if, upon considering the police report, documents, and hearing both sides, the Magistrate finds no ground to proceed. - Trial of Summons Cases (Under Chapter XX of CrPC):
Discharge is not explicitly provided for in summons cases. However, the accused may request dropping of proceedings or quashing of the complaint under specific circumstances.
3. Grounds for Discharge
The application must demonstrate that:
- No Prima Facie Case Exists: The evidence on record does not establish the essential ingredients of the alleged offense.
- Lack of Legal Evidence: Evidence provided is inadmissible or insufficient to justify a trial.
- Absence of Mens Rea or Actus Reus: There is no evidence of guilty intent or conduct on the part of the accused.
- Case is Malicious or Frivolous: The case has been filed with ulterior motives or lacks genuine substance.
4. Filing the Application
Step 1: Drafting the Application
- The application should be supported by legal grounds, facts of the case, and relevant judgments.
- It should include all documents, evidence, and the charge sheet for the court’s consideration.
Step 2: Filing in the Appropriate Court
- File the application in the court where the case is pending (Magistrate’s Court or Sessions Court).
- Ensure compliance with procedural rules of the court.
Step 3: Hearing on the Application
- The court will consider arguments from both the prosecution and the accused.
- If the court finds insufficient grounds to proceed, it will discharge the accused.
5. Key Judgments Supporting Discharge
- State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (1992): Outlined instances where criminal proceedings may be quashed.
- Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal (1979): Established principles for discharge, including evaluating whether the materials on record make out a prima facie case.
6. Alternate Remedy: Quashing under Section 482 of CrPC
If the accused believes the proceedings are entirely baseless, they can approach the High Court under Section 482 to quash the proceedings.
For Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644. This Suggestion is Absolutely Free.