strict

Doctrine of strict liability.

The doctrine of strict liability is a legal principle that holds a party responsible for damages or injuries caused by their actions or products, regardless of fault or intent. This means that even if the party took all possible precautions, they can still be held liable.

Key Aspects of Strict Liability:

  1. No Need to Prove Negligence: Unlike negligence cases, the injured party does not have to prove that the defendant was careless or intended harm.
  2. Applies to Inherently Dangerous Activities: It is often applied to activities that are inherently risky, such as:
    • Manufacturing and selling defective products (Product Liability)
    • Keeping dangerous animals (Animal Liability)
    • Engaging in hazardous activities like using explosives or storing toxic substances (Ultrahazardous Activities)
  3. Defenses Are Limited: Common defenses like lack of intent or due care do not apply, but some exceptions exist, such as misuse of a product.

Examples of Strict Liability:

  • A company sells a defective car part that causes an accident.
  • A person’s pet tiger escapes and injures someone.
  • A construction company uses dynamite, causing unintended damage to nearby buildings.

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

443373-supreme-court-sc-08

Section 47 CPC Applications Raising Property Rights After Passing Of Decree To Be Treated As Application Under Order 21 Rule 97 : Supreme Court

The Supreme Court recently observed that an application filed under Section 47 of CPC relating to the determination of questions related to the execution of the decree would be deemed as an application filed under Order XXI Rule 97 if it raises questions of right, title, or interest in the property.

The Court clarified that while applications under Section 47 of the CPC and Order 21 Rule 97 address distinct proceedings— with the former concerning execution, discharge, or satisfaction of a decree and the latter dealing with resistance or obstruction to possession, including by third parties— an application under Section 47 filed by a judgment debtor or an aggrieved third party will be treated as one under Order 21 Rule 97 if it raises questions of right, title, or interest in the property. In such cases, the executing court must adjudicate these questions under Order 21 Rule 101.

Also Read – Refusal Of Alleged Rape Victim To Allow Medical Examination Raises Negative Inference Against Her : Supreme Court

A bench comprising Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice Pankaj Mithal heard the case, in which the respondents filed an application under Section 47 of CPC after a decree was passed in the appellant’s favor, asserting their status as bona fide cultivating tenants to prevent their dispossession from the property.

In the judgment authored by Justice Pardiwala, the Court observed that although the respondent had filed an application under Section 47 of the CPC—where the executing court is not required to adjudicate issues related to rights, interest, or title in the property—it would be treated as an application under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC, eliminating the need for a separate application under that provision.

Also Read – Every Document Pertaining To An Election Is Important, All Efforts Should Be Made To Preserve Them : Supreme Court

The Court reasoned that since the application under Section 47 CPC raises objections concerning rights in the property, which the executing court cannot determine after the decree has been passed, reclassifying it as an application under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC would empower the executing court to adjudicate such issues. This approach aligns with the legal principle that the executing court cannot question the validity of the decree or go beyond its scope.

Also Read – Advocate Cannot Give Undertaking To Court Without Client’s Explicit Authority : Supreme Court

Applying the law to the facts, the Court observed that the respondents had claimed to be bona fide cultivating tenants to resist dispossession after the decree was passed—an issue they could have raised during the trial. Consequently, the Court treated their Section 47 application as one under Order 21 Rule 97 and adjudicated it under Rule 101. It ultimately held that the respondents had failed to establish an independent right to possession and that their objections were collusive, raised only after the decree was passed.

In such circumstances referred to above the application of the respondents No. 1 and 2 under Section 47 of the CPC bearing R.E.A. No. 163 of 2011 was in substance an application for determination of their possessory rights under Order XXI Rule 97.”, the Court observed.

Also From JudgmentDirect Courts To Dispose Execution Petitions Within 6 Months, Hold Presiding Officer Liable On Failure : Supreme Court Asks High Courts

Case Details: PERIYAMMAL (DEAD THR. LRS.) AND ORS Versus V. RAJAMANI AND ANR. ETC|SLP(C) No. 8490-8492/2020

Citation : 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 293

Click here to read the judgment

WRITTT

TYPE OF WRIT PETITIONS

A writ petition is a formal written request to a court seeking relief or enforcement of a legal right. In India, writ petitions are filed under Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts) of the Constitution. There are five main types of writs:

1. Habeas Corpus

  • Meaning: “Produce the body”
  • Purpose: To protect an individual’s right to personal liberty against unlawful detention or arrest.
  • Example: If a person is detained illegally by the police or any private individual, their family or friends can file this writ.

2. Mandamus

  • Meaning: “We command”
  • Purpose: To direct a public official, government body, or lower court to perform a duty they are legally required to do.
  • Example: If a government official refuses to issue a necessary license without valid reason, a writ of mandamus can be filed.

3. Prohibition

  • Meaning: “To forbid”
  • Purpose: To prevent a lower court, tribunal, or quasi-judicial body from exceeding its jurisdiction or acting against the law.
  • Example: If a lower court starts hearing a case it has no authority to hear, the High Court or Supreme Court can issue this writ.

4. Certiorari

  • Meaning: “To be certified”
  • Purpose: To quash an illegal or improper order passed by a lower court, tribunal, or authority.
  • Example: If a tribunal gives a decision beyond its jurisdiction, the higher court can annul it using certiorari.

5. Quo Warranto

  • Meaning: “By what authority”
  • Purpose: To challenge the legal validity of a person’s claim to a public office.
  • Example: If someone is appointed as a government officer without fulfilling the required qualifications, this writ can be filed to remove them.

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

gunlicense

How to Get a Gun licence in india?

In India, obtaining a gun license is a regulated process governed by the Arms Act of 1959 and the Arms Rules of 2016. The process involves multiple steps, background checks, and strict criteria. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you understand how to apply for a gun license in India:

✅ Eligibility Criteria
You must meet the following conditions to apply for a gun license:

Age: Minimum 21 years old.
Reason for License: You must provide a valid reason, such as:
Self-defense
Crop protection (for farmers)
Sports (shooting competitions)
Business security (for banks or jewelry stores)
Criminal Record: No history of criminal activity or mental illness.

📋 Application Process
Obtain and Fill the Application Form

Collect Form A from your local District Superintendent of Police (DSP) office or download it from the official Ministry of Home Affairs website.
Provide accurate details like:
Personal information
Type of firearm requested (pistol, revolver, rifle, etc.)
Justification for the firearm
Submit Required Documents
Attach the following documents:

Identity proof (Aadhaar card, PAN card, passport)
Address proof (utility bill, rental agreement)
Date of birth proof (birth certificate)
Income proof (salary slip, ITR)
Medical certificate (certifying mental and physical fitness)
Character verification from local authorities
Police Verification

Police will conduct a thorough background check to assess your criminal record and character.
They may interview neighbors and local authorities.
Personal Interview

You may be called for an interview with the licensing authority to explain your reason for needing a firearm.
Decision by Licensing Authority

Based on the investigation, the authority (usually the District Magistrate or Commissioner of Police) will either approve or reject your application.
Training Certification (if required)

You may need to complete a firearms safety training program and submit a certificate of completion.

🧾 Fees and Validity
Application Fee: ₹500 to ₹1,000 (varies by state and type of firearm).
License Validity: Generally valid for 3 years and must be renewed before expiration.

⚠️ Important Notes
Strict Scrutiny: Only genuine and verified applicants are granted licenses.
Illegal Possession: Owning a gun without a valid license is a criminal offense under Indian law.

Renewal Process: Apply for renewal at least 6 months before expiration.

mercy

mercy petition in death sentence cases

A mercy petition in death sentence cases is a last resort for a convict to seek clemency after exhausting all judicial remedies. It is a request for pardon, commutation, or remission of the sentence, submitted to the President of India (at the national level) or the Governor of a state.

Legal Provisions for Mercy Petition in India

  1. Under the Indian Constitution:
    • Article 72: The President has the power to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions of punishment in cases of:
      • Court Martial
      • Offenses against Union laws
      • Death sentence cases
    • Article 161: The Governor has similar powers but cannot grant mercy in cases of the death penalty.
  2. Under the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Santhita (BNSS), 2023
    • Section 473 ,474& 475: Allows the government to suspend or remit sentences.
    • Section 476: Allows the central government to act in cases where the state government has jurisdiction.
    • Section 477: Requires the state government to consult the central government in certain cases.

Procedure for Filing a Mercy Petition

  1. The convict or their family submits a mercy petition to the President of India through the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA).
  2. The MHA seeks the opinion of the concerned state government and court records.
  3. The petition is reviewed by the Home Minister, who then forwards a recommendation to the President.
  4. The President exercises discretion and decides to either accept or reject the petition.

Possible Outcomes of a Mercy Petition

  • Pardon: Complete relief from punishment.
  • Commutation: Substituting a lesser punishment (e.g., life imprisonment instead of a death sentence).
  • Remission: Reduction in the term of the sentence.
  • Respite: Lesser sentence due to special circumstances (e.g., pregnancy).
  • Reprieve: Temporary delay in execution.

Landmark Cases on Mercy Petitions

  1. Kehar Singh v. Union of India (1989): The Supreme Court held that the President’s power under Article 72 is of wide amplitude, and judicial review is limited.
  2. Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014): The Court ruled that undue delay in deciding mercy petitions is a valid ground for commuting a death sentence.
  3. Dhananjoy Chatterjee case (2004): The first hanging in India post-1989; his mercy petition was rejected.

Judicial Review of Mercy Petitions

Although the President’s decision is final, it can be challenged in court on limited grounds, such as:

  • Arbitrary or mala fide rejection
  • Violation of fundamental rights (Article 21)
  • Inordinate delay in decision-making

Recent Developments

  • The Supreme Court has ruled that mercy petitions must be decided expeditiously to avoid mental agony for the convict.
  • In cases like Yakub Memon (2015) and Nirbhaya case convicts (2020), the rejection of mercy petitions was done swiftly.
against-marriage

Prosecution for offences against marriage in BNSS.

Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023, Section 219 outlines the procedures for prosecuting offences against marriage as defined in Sections 81 to 84 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023. These offences include:

  1. Dowry Death (Section 80): Pertains to the death of a woman caused by burns, bodily injury, or occurring under unnatural circumstances within seven years of marriage, linked to dowry-related harassment.
  2. Marrying Again During Lifetime of Husband or Wife (Section 82): Addresses bigamy, where an individual marries another person while their spouse is still alive, rendering the subsequent marriage void.
  3. Marriage Ceremony Fraudulently Gone Through Without Lawful Marriage (Section 83): Involves deceitfully conducting a marriage ceremony without a lawful marriage.
  4. Adultery (Section 84): Concerns engaging in sexual relations with someone who is married to another person.

Key Provisions of Section 219 BNSS:

  • Complaint by Aggrieved Person: Generally, only the person directly aggrieved by the offence can file a complaint.
  • Exceptions:
    • If the aggrieved person is a child, of unsound mind, has an intellectual disability requiring higher support needs, is sick or infirm, or is a woman who, according to local customs, should not be compelled to appear in public, another person may file the complaint with the court’s permission.
    • If the aggrieved person is serving in the Armed Forces under conditions preventing them from obtaining leave, an authorized individual may file the complaint on their behalf.
    • For offences under Section 82 (bigamy), if the aggrieved person is the wife, her close relatives—such as father, mother, brother, sister, son, or daughter—may file the complaint. With the court’s permission, any other person related by blood, marriage, or adoption can also do so.

These provisions ensure that offences against marriage are addressed appropriately, even when the directly aggrieved individual cannot personally initiate legal proceedings.

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

attach-cpc

How can A Degree holder attach the property of judgement debtor according CPC?

In India, the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) governs the procedure for attaching the property of a judgment debtor when executing a decree. If you are a decree holder (i.e., a person in whose favor a court has passed a decree), you can follow these steps to attach the property of the judgment debtor:

Steps to Attach the Property of a Judgment Debtor under CPC:

1. File an Execution Petition (Order 21, Rule 11)

  • The decree holder must file an execution petition before the court that passed the decree or the court to which it is transferred.
  • The petition should include:
    • Case details
    • Details of the judgment debtor
    • Details of the decree (money decree or any other)
    • Request for attachment of property

2. Identify the Property for Attachment

  • The decree holder should provide details of the property (movable or immovable) belonging to the judgment debtor.
  • If details are unknown, an application can be filed under Order 21, Rule 41 to compel the judgment debtor to disclose assets.

3. Court Issues a Notice to Judgment Debtor (Order 21, Rule 22)

  • If more than two years have passed since the decree or the judgment debtor was not a party to the decree, the court must issue a notice before proceeding with attachment.

4. Court Orders Attachment of Property (Order 21, Rules 54 & 43)

  • If the judgment debtor does not satisfy the decree, the court may order the attachment of:
    • Movable Property (Order 21, Rule 43) – Seizure by court officers.
    • Immovable Property (Order 21, Rule 54) – Public proclamation and prohibition of sale/transfer.

5. Sale of Attached Property (Order 21, Rule 64)

  • If the debtor fails to pay even after attachment, the court may order the sale of the property through public auction.
  • The sale proceeds will be used to satisfy the decree.

Important Restrictions on Attachment

  • Certain properties cannot be attached, such as:
    • Necessary household items (Section 60, CPC)
    • Salary of a government employee beyond a certain limit
    • Pension, Provident Fund, etc.

Conclusion

To attach the property of a judgment debtor, a decree holder must file an execution petition, identify the property, and follow CPC procedures for attachment and sale. If the debtor refuses to comply, the court has the power to enforce execution through various means.

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

written

How should be A Defendant give his written statement according CPC?

A written statement under the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), 1908 is a crucial document in which the defendant responds to the claims made by the plaintiff in a suit. It should be drafted carefully in compliance with Order VIII of the CPC. Below are the key points to be considered:

1. Timeline for Submission

  • As per Order VIII Rule 1, the defendant should file the written statement within 30 days from the date of service of summons.
  • If not filed within 30 days, the court may allow an extension up to 90 days for sufficient cause.

2. Structure of a Written Statement

A written statement should include the following:

a. Heading & Title

  • The document should be titled “Written Statement” and include the case details (Court name, Case Number, Plaintiff & Defendant Names).

b. Preliminary Submissions

  • Mention objections related to jurisdiction, maintainability, or any other preliminary issues (like locus standi, limitation, etc.).

c. Para-wise Reply to the Plaintiff’s Claims

  • Each paragraph of the plaint should be replied to specifically.
  • The defendant should either admit, deny, or state lack of knowledge about each allegation.
  • Vague or evasive denials may be considered as an admission under Order VIII Rule 5 CPC.

d. Statement of Facts

  • Provide the defendant’s version of facts, which contradicts or clarifies the plaintiff’s allegations.

e. Legal Defenses (Plea in Law)

  • The defendant must state the legal grounds on which the plaintiff’s claim is opposed.
  • Example: Limitation, lack of cause of action, fraud, etc.

f. Counterclaim or Set-off (If Applicable)

  • If the defendant has any claim against the plaintiff, he can file a counterclaim under Order VIII Rule 6-A or a set-off under Order VIII Rule 6.

g. Prayer Clause

  • The defendant should clearly specify what relief they seek, such as dismissal of the suit with costs.

h. Verification

  • The written statement must be signed and verified by the defendant or their authorized agent, as per Order VI Rule 15 CPC.

3. Important Rules to Remember

  • No new facts should be introduced unnecessarily unless they form part of a counterclaim or defense.
  • If a fact is not specifically denied, it may be deemed admitted.
  • The written statement must be signed by the defendant and supported by an affidavit as per the Commercial Courts Act (if applicable)

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

kidnapping-new

How the accused can get relief in kidnapping?

The relief available to an accused person in a kidnapping case depends on the circumstances of the case, the applicable laws, and the legal defenses available. Here are some common ways an accused person may seek relief:

1. Bail

  • The accused can apply for bail before the trial begins.
  • If the offense is bailable, bail may be granted easily.
  • If it is non-bailable, the accused must prove that they are not a flight risk and will not tamper with evidence.

2. Lack of Evidence

  • If the prosecution fails to provide sufficient evidence, the accused can be acquitted.
  • The defense lawyer can challenge witness statements, CCTV footage, call records, etc.

3. False Allegations & Malicious Prosecution

  • If the kidnapping charge was filed due to personal enmity, family disputes, or false allegations, the accused can provide proof of an alibi or contradictory evidence.

4. Consent of the Alleged Victim

  • If the alleged victim willingly went with the accused (especially in cases involving elopement of adults), it can be a defense.
  • In some cases, the court may consider whether the victim was a consenting adult.

5. Mistaken Identity

  • If the accused was wrongly identified as the kidnapper, they can present an alibi, witnesses, or other proof to show they were not involved.

6. No Criminal Intent

  • If the accused did not have the intention to kidnap, they may argue that the act was misunderstood or accidental.

7. Plea Bargaining

  • In some jurisdictions, the accused can negotiate a lesser charge or reduced sentence through plea bargaining.

8. Quashing the FIR

  • If the case is based on false or weak grounds, the accused can file a petition to quash the FIR in a higher court (like the High Court in India under Section 582 BNSS).

9. Appeal After Conviction

  • If convicted, the accused can file an appeal in a higher court to challenge the decision.

Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644.

dv-punishmnet

how the accused can face punishment in Domestic Violence (DV) case?

In a Domestic Violence (DV) case, the punishment for the accused depends on the laws of the country and the specific circumstances of the case. Below are some general ways an accused may face punishment:

1. Criminal Penalties (If Domestic Violence is a Criminal Offense)

  • Jail or Prison Sentence – The accused may face imprisonment depending on the severity of the offense.
  • Fines – The court may impose monetary fines as punishment.
  • Probation – The accused may be placed under supervision with conditions such as attending counseling, avoiding the victim, or doing community service.
  • Restraining Orders (Protection Orders) – The court may order the accused to stay away from the victim, their home, or workplace.
  • Mandatory Counseling or Rehabilitation – The accused may be required to attend anger management programs, domestic violence intervention programs, or substance abuse treatment.

2. Civil Consequences (If the Case is a Civil Matter)

  • Compensation to the Victim – The accused may be ordered to pay damages for medical expenses, emotional distress, or financial losses.
  • Loss of Child Custody or Visitation Rights – If the accused has children with the victim, they may lose custody or have restricted visitation rights.
  • Eviction from Shared Residence – The court may order the accused to leave the home shared with the victim.

3. Other Consequences

  • Loss of Job or Employment Issues – A domestic violence conviction may lead to termination from employment, especially in professions requiring a clean criminal record.
  • Travel Restrictions – Some countries deny visas or entry to people with domestic violence convictions.
  • Social Stigma – A DV conviction can affect personal relationships, reputation, and social standing.

Can the Accused Avoid Punishment?

  • By Proving Innocence – If the accused can prove that the allegations are false or exaggerated, they may avoid punishment.
  • Settlement or Mediation – In some cases, a settlement between the parties may lead to case withdrawal (depending on the law).
  • Legal Defenses – The accused can argue self-defense, lack of evidence, or false accusations with the help of a lawyer.