How can be removing a respondent (or a defendant) from a legal proceeding in CPC ?

In the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), a respondent or defendant can be removed from a legal proceeding under certain circumstances, typically by invoking specific provisions of the CPC. Here’s how this can be achieved:

1. Rule for Misjoinder or Nonjoinder of Parties (Order I, Rule 10 CPC)

• Key Provision: Order I, Rule 10(2) of the CPC empowers the court to strike out or add parties.
• Grounds for Removal:
  • The defendant or respondent is improperly joined (misjoinder).
  • The presence of the defendant or respondent is not necessary for the determination of the matter or for granting effective relief to the plaintiff.
  • Their inclusion does not aid the court in resolving the real questions involved in the suit.

Procedure:

• The plaintiff or any party may apply to the court for the removal of the defendant or respondent.
• The court can also act suo motu (on its own) to strike out a party.

Example:

If a person was mistakenly added as a defendant, or their role in the case is irrelevant, they can be removed under this provision.

2. Dismissal of a Suit Against a Particular Defendant (Order XXIII, Rule 1 CPC)

• Key Provision: A plaintiff may withdraw their claim or suit against a particular defendant.
• Grounds for Removal:
  • The plaintiff voluntarily decides to withdraw the case against the defendant.
  • The withdrawal does not prejudice other parties involved in the case.

Procedure:

• The plaintiff must file an application to withdraw the suit against the defendant.
• The court may grant permission, often imposing conditions (e.g., costs to the defendant).

3. Rejection of Plaint Against a Particular Defendant (Order VII, Rule 11 CPC)

• If the plaint does not disclose a cause of action against a particular defendant, the defendant may be removed from the case.

Grounds:

• No cause of action exists against the defendant.
• The suit is barred by law against the particular defendant.

Procedure:

• The defendant may file an application under Order VII, Rule 11.
• The court will assess the application and decide whether the plaint can be rejected against that specific defendant.

4. Compromise or Settlement (Order XXIII, Rule 3 CPC)

• If the plaintiff and the defendant reach a compromise or settlement, the defendant can be effectively removed from the proceeding.

Procedure:

• The terms of the settlement are recorded, and the defendant’s role is discharged.

5. Inherent Powers of the Court (Section 151 CPC)

• Key Provision: Section 151 empowers the court to act in the interest of justice when no specific provision exists in the CPC.
• Grounds:
  • The defendant or respondent’s inclusion is unnecessary and leads to a waste of judicial time.
  • Their removal is necessary to avoid abuse of the process of the court.

Procedure:

• An application can be made by any party or the court may act suo motu.

Important Points:

• Court’s Discretion: The decision to remove a defendant or respondent lies at the discretion of the court, which considers the necessity and relevancy of the party in resolving the dispute.
• Impact of Removal: The removal of a defendant or respondent should not adversely affect the rights of the remaining parties or hinder the resolution of the main issues.
• Application: Ensure the application for removal is clear, supported by evidence, and demonstrates the lack of necessity for the defendant’s presence in the case.

For Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644. This Suggestion is Absolutely Free.