what is the safeguards for men from 498a IPC (85 BNS) ?

Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) is a criminal provision aimed at protecting women from cruelty by their husbands or relatives of the husband. However, allegations under Section 498A can sometimes be misused. To address such concerns, various safeguards have been put in place for men accused under this section. Here are the key safeguards:

1. Judicial Guidelines

Courts in India have issued guidelines to prevent the misuse of Section 498A:

• Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014): The Supreme Court directed that:
  • Arrests under Section 498A should not be made automatically.
  • Police must satisfy the necessity of arrest and record reasons in writing.
  • Accused persons should ordinarily be served a notice to appear before the police (under Section 41A Cr.P.C.) instead of being arrested immediately.

2. Pre-Arrest Safeguards

• Anticipatory Bail (Section 438 Cr.P.C.): If a man apprehends arrest under Section 498A, he can apply for anticipatory bail, which protects him from immediate custody.
• Notice of Appearance: The Arnesh Kumar judgment emphasizes that police must issue a notice under Section 41A of Cr.P.C., ensuring the accused gets an opportunity to cooperate with the investigation before any arrest.

3. Mediation and Reconciliation

• Many courts encourage mediation or alternative dispute resolution between the parties at an early stage to resolve marital disputes and avoid prolonged litigation.

4. Scrutiny by Family Welfare Committees

• In Rajesh Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017), the Supreme Court introduced the concept of Family Welfare Committees to examine complaints before the police register an FIR. Although later modified, this reflects judicial acknowledgment of potential misuse.

5. Stringent Bail Rules for Misuse

• If the complainant misuses Section 498A for false allegations, the accused may bring it to the notice of the court. In such cases, courts can impose penalties or direct action against the complainant.

6. Provision for Counter-Action

• Section 182 IPC: The accused can file a complaint if it is proven that the complainant lodged a false case with malicious intent.
• Defamation (Section 500 IPC): The accused can file a defamation case if their reputation is damaged due to false accusations.
• Malicious Prosecution: The accused can seek damages for malicious prosecution if they are acquitted.

7. No Automatic Custody

• Courts are vigilant in safeguarding the rights of the accused, ensuring that no automatic or mechanical custody is imposed without proper investigation.

8. Role of Evidence

• The burden of proving cruelty lies with the prosecution. Mere allegations without substantial evidence are insufficient for conviction.

9. Right to a Speedy Trial

• The accused has the right to demand a speedy trial, preventing prolonged harassment due to delays in the legal process.

10. Guidance for Police

• The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and the Supreme Court have issued clear guidelines to the police to prevent misuse of Section 498A:
  • Conduct preliminary investigations before registering an FIR.
  • Ensure compliance with judicial directives.

11. Case Law Supporting Accused Rights

• Sushil Kumar Sharma v. Union of India (2005): The Supreme Court acknowledged that misuse of Section 498A should not lead to the harassment of innocent individuals.
• Preeti Gupta v. State of Jharkhand (2010): The Court highlighted that frivolous complaints should be dealt with firmly.

Practical Steps for the Accused:

1. Collect Evidence: Preserve emails, messages, and other communications that may counter allegations.
2. Legal Representation: Engage a competent lawyer experienced in handling 498A cases.
3. Document Events: Maintain a diary of incidents and interactions with the complainant.
4. Be Cooperative: Cooperate with the investigation while ensuring your rights are protected.

By leveraging these safeguards, men falsely accused under Section 498A can protect their legal rights and defend themselves effectively.

For Any Type Of Consultation Or Suggestion Call Us On +91 9211732039 / +91 9891045644. This Suggestion is Absolutely free.