Order 18 Rule 4 CPC – Examination-in-Chief by Affidavit

Order 18 Rule 4 CPC Explained: Affidavit Evidence, Procedure, Example & Key Points

Provision Overview

Order 18 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) deals with the mode of recording evidence, specifically:

Examination-in-chief shall be given by affidavit
Cross-examination & re-examination happen in court or before a commissioner

Bare Provision (Simplified)

• Examination-in-chief = By Affidavit
• Cross-examination = In Court / Before Commissioner
• Documents = Filed along with affidavit
• Court may appoint Commissioner for recording evidence

Purpose of Order 18 Rule 4

✔ Speed up trial
✔ Reduce court time
✔ Avoid unnecessary oral recording
✔ Ensure efficient evidence process

Procedure (Step-by-Step)

1️. Filing of Affidavit

• Party files Evidence Affidavit
• Includes all facts, documents, exhibits

2️. Admission/Denial of Documents

• Opposite party checks documents
• Raises objections

3️. Cross-Examination

• Conducted:
  • In Court OR
  • Before Local Commissioner

4️. Re-Examination

• Limited to clarification

5️. Closure of Evidence

• After all witnesses examined

Example (Practical Understanding)

Case: Property Dispute

• Plaintiff files affidavit evidence stating:
  • Ownership of property
  • Supporting documents (Sale Deed, Registry)
• Defendant:
  • Cross-examines plaintiff
  • Challenges authenticity of documents

Court decides based on:

• Affidavit
• Cross-examination
• Documentary evidence

Key Points (Very Important)

✔ Examination-in-chief is NOT oral (only affidavit)
✔ Affidavit = Substantive evidence
✔ Cross-examination is mandatory right
✔ Commissioner can record evidence
✔ Documents must be filed with affidavit

Important Legal Position

Affidavit without cross-examination = weak evidence

If witness is not produced for cross:

• Evidence may be ignored

Practical Court Tips

✔ Always draft detailed affidavit
✔ Attach all relevant documents
✔ Prepare witness for cross-examination
✔ Highlight contradictions during cross

Common Mistakes

❌ Filing incomplete affidavit
❌ Not attaching documents
❌ Avoiding cross-examination
❌ Vague statements without proof

Important Judgments

Ameer Trading Corporation Ltd. v. Shapoorji Data Processing Ltd.

Held: Examination-in-chief by affidavit is valid and mandatory

Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India

Upheld amendment for speedy trial

Drafting Tip (For Advocates)

Start affidavit with:

• Name, age, address
• Facts in numbered paras
• Documents marked as Exhibits

Conclusion

Order 18 Rule 4 CPC is a crucial provision that:

• Speeds up civil trials
• Makes affidavit evidence primary
• Ensures structured cross-examination

Proper use of this provision can strengthen your case significantly

For Educational & Legal Awareness
Website: www.ushavatsassociates.in