Best Advocate In Dwarka Court

Legal Notice under Sections 2(10), 2(21), 2(47) & 39

of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019**

1. Section 2(10) – “Consumer”

Meaning:
A consumer is a person who:

  • Buys goods or hires/avails services for consideration
  • Includes online, e-commerce, teleshopping purchases
  • Does not include goods/services taken for resale or commercial purpose (except self-employment)

Purpose in Legal Notice:
To establish that the complainant legally qualifies as a consumer under the Act.


2. Section 2(21) – “Deficiency”

Meaning:
Any fault, imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in:

  • Quality
  • Nature
  • Manner of performance
  • Service promised by law or contract

Examples:

  • Delay in delivery
  • Poor service
  • Non-refund
  • Incomplete work

Purpose in Legal Notice:
To prove deficiency in service by the opposite party.


3. Section 2(47) – “Unfair Trade Practice”

Meaning:
Any unfair or deceptive practice, including:

  • False representation
  • Misleading advertisements
  • Charging excess price
  • Concealment of material facts

Purpose in Legal Notice:
To show that the service provider indulged in fraudulent or misleading conduct.


Section 39 – Reliefs Available to Consumer

Consumer Commission may order:
✔ Removal of defects
✔ Replacement of goods
✔ Refund of amount paid
✔ Compensation for loss/mental agony
✔ Discontinuation of unfair trade practice
✔ Withdrawal of misleading advertisement
✔ Punitive damages (where applicable)

Purpose in Legal Notice:
To formally demand reliefs and warn of legal action before filing a consumer complaint.


Why This Legal Notice Is Issued

  • To give the service provider one final opportunity to resolve the dispute
  • To comply with principles of natural justice
  • To avoid litigation if settlement is possible

Common Situations Where This Notice Is Used

  • Builder–buyer disputes
  • Online shopping fraud
  • Defective products
  • Insurance claim rejection
  • Medical negligence
  • Travel & hospitality disputes
  • Coaching institute fraud

Standard Closing Line (Sample)

If you fail to comply within 15 days, my client shall be constrained to initiate appropriate proceedings before the Consumer Commission at your sole risk, cost, and consequences.

CASE LAWS SUPPORTING CONSUMER LEGAL NOTICE

(CPA, 2019 – Definitions, Deficiency & Reliefs)


1. Who is a “Consumer” – Section 2(10)

Laxmi Engineering Works v. P.S.G. Industrial Institute

(1995) 3 SCC 583 – Supreme Court

✔ Held that:

  • A person purchasing goods/services for self-use or livelihood is a consumer
  • Commercial purpose must be interpreted narrowly

Use in Notice:

Establishes complainant’s status as a “consumer”.


Kavita Ahuja v. Shipra Estates Ltd.

I (2016) CPJ 31 (NC)

✔ Buyer of flat is a consumer
✔ Delay/defects amount to deficiency

Useful for: Builder-buyer disputes


2. Deficiency in Service – Section 2(21)

Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta

(1994) 1 SCC 243 – Supreme Court

✔ Deficiency includes:

  • Delay
  • Negligence
  • Harassment
  • Mental agony

Landmark case – most cited in consumer notices


Haryana Urban Development Authority v. Raje Ram

(2008) 17 SCC 407

✔ Failure to deliver promised service = deficiency
✔ Compensation is justified


Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Balbir Singh

(2004) 5 SCC 65

✔ Consumer Commissions can grant:

  • Compensation
  • Interest
  • Mental agony damages

3. Unfair Trade Practice – Section 2(47)

Skypak Couriers Ltd. v. Tata Chemicals Ltd.

(2000) 5 SCC 294

✔ Misrepresentation & false assurances = unfair trade practice
✔ Disclaimers cannot override consumer rights


DLF Ltd. v. Mridul Estate Pvt. Ltd.

(2013) 14 SCC 22

✔ One-sided terms & misleading promises are unfair trade practices

Use when:

  • Hidden charges
  • False advertising
  • One-sided contracts

4. Reliefs by Consumer Commission – Section 39

Charan Singh v. Healing Touch Hospital

(2000) 7 SCC 668 – Supreme Court

✔ Compensation must:

  • Redress injury
  • Deter wrongdoing
  • Be realistic & just

Spring Meadows Hospital v. Harjol Ahluwalia

(1998) 4 SCC 39

✔ Compensation can be awarded for:

  • Mental agony
  • Harassment
  • Negligent service

5. Online / E-commerce Consumers Covered

Amazon Seller Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Amrita Nanda

2022 (NC)

✔ Online buyers are consumers
✔ Platform liability recognised

Very relevant for e-commerce disputes


HOW TO CITE IN LEGAL NOTICE (Sample Line)

“The acts of your client squarely fall within the definition of ‘deficiency in service’ under Section 2(21) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta (1994) 1 SCC 243…”

Stages of Writ Petition - Best Advocate In Dwarka

Stages of a Writ Petition (Article 226 / Article 32)

1. Cause of Action

  • Violation of a Fundamental Right or legal/statutory right
  • Illegal, arbitrary, or unconstitutional act by the State or public authority

2. Drafting of the Writ Petition

The petition is drafted mentioning:

  • Jurisdiction (Article 226 – High Court / 32 – Supreme Court)
  • Details of parties (Petitioner & Respondents)
  • Statement of facts
  • Grounds of challenge
  • Reliefs sought
  • Prayer for interim relief (if any)
  • Supporting affidavit and annexures

3. Filing of Petition

  • E-filing or physical filing before the Registry
  • A diary number / filing number is allotted

4. Scrutiny by Registry

  • Registry examines the petition for defects
  • Objections (if any) are raised

5. Removal of Defects

  • Petitioner/advocate cures defects pointed out by the Registry
  • Petition is marked as complete

6. Listing for Admission (Preliminary Hearing)

  • Case is listed before the appropriate Bench
  • Court may:
    • Issue notice
    • Seek clarification
    • Dismiss the petition at threshold

7. Issuance of Notice

  • Notice is issued to the respondent(s)
  • Respondents are directed to file their reply

8. Interim Relief Stage (If Applicable)

  • Court may grant:
    • Stay order
    • Status quo
    • Protection from coercive action
  • Interim relief may be allowed or refused

9. Counter Affidavit by Respondents

  • Respondents file their reply
  • Justification of the impugned action

10. Rejoinder by Petitioner

  • Petitioner files rejoinder
  • Reply to the counter affidavit

11. Final Hearing / Arguments

  • Detailed oral submissions by both sides
  • Reliance on case laws and statutory provisions

12. Judgment Reserved / Pronounced

  • Court may reserve judgment or pronounce it immediately

13. Final Order / Judgment

  • Petition may be:
    • Allowed
    • Dismissed
    • Partly allowed
  • Directions issued to authorities

14. Compliance of Order

  • Respondents must comply with the court’s directions
  • Non-compliance may lead to Contempt Proceedings

Types of Writs (Quick Reference)

  • Habeas Corpus
  • Mandamus
  • Certiorari
  • Prohibition
  • Quo Warranto

Key Points

  • Generally, disputed questions of fact are avoided
  • Alternative remedy rule applies (with exceptions)
  • Writ jurisdiction is discretionary and equitable

Best Advocate In Dwarka Court - Usha Vats & Associates

Types of Legal Notices in India

1. Civil Legal Notice

Applicable Laws:

  • Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
  • Indian Contract Act, 1872

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued before filing a civil suit to:

  • Demand performance of obligation
  • Seek recovery of money/property
  • Give last opportunity to settle dispute

📌 Common in:

  • Property disputes
  • Recovery suits
  • Injunction matters

2. Legal Notice under Section 80 CPC (Notice to Government)

Applicable Act:

  • Section 80, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908

Purpose / Meaning:
Mandatory notice before filing a suit against:

  • Central / State Government
  • Public officers for official acts

2 months’ notice is compulsory (except urgent cases).


3. Cheque Bounce Legal Notice

Applicable Act:

  • Section 138, Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

Purpose / Meaning:
Sent by payee to drawer when cheque is dishonoured:

  • Demands payment within 15 days
  • Mandatory before filing criminal complaint

Without notice → case not maintainable.


4. Consumer Legal Notice

Applicable Act:

  • Consumer Protection Act, 2019

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued against:

  • Defective goods
  • Deficient services
  • Unfair trade practices

Not mandatory, but strongly recommended.


5. Legal Notice for Recovery of Money

Applicable Acts:

  • Indian Contract Act, 1872
  • CPC, 1908

Purpose / Meaning:
To demand payment of:

  • Loan
  • Outstanding dues
  • Professional fees

Often leads to settlement without litigation.


6. Employment / Labour Legal Notice

Applicable Laws:

  • Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Shops & Establishments Acts
  • Contract Act

Purpose / Meaning:
Used by employer or employee for:

  • Illegal termination
  • Salary dues
  • Breach of employment contract

7. Legal Notice for Divorce / Matrimonial Disputes

Applicable Acts:

  • Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
  • Special Marriage Act, 1954
  • Muslim / Christian personal laws

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued for:

  • Divorce intention
  • Maintenance
  • Restitution of conjugal rights

Acts as pre-litigation intimation.


8. Legal Notice for Property Matters

Applicable Acts:

  • Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • CPC, 1908

Purpose / Meaning:
Used for:

  • Eviction
  • Possession
  • Encroachment
  • Partition disputes

9. Tenant–Landlord Legal Notice

Applicable Acts:

  • Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Rent Control Acts (State-specific)

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued for:

  • Termination of tenancy
  • Rent arrears
  • Eviction demand

10. Copyright / Trademark / IP Legal Notice

Applicable Acts:

  • Copyright Act, 1957
  • Trade Marks Act, 1999
  • Patents Act, 1970

Purpose / Meaning:
Sent to stop:

  • Infringement
  • Unauthorized use
  • Passing off

Often called Cease & Desist Notice.


11. Defamation Legal Notice

Applicable Laws:

  • IPC / BNS (Criminal Defamation)
  • Law of Torts (Civil Defamation)

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued for:

  • False allegations
  • Reputation damage
  • Media / social media content

12. Company / Corporate Legal Notice

Applicable Acts:

  • Companies Act, 2013
  • Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016

Purpose / Meaning:
Used for:

  • Shareholder disputes
  • Oppression & mismanagement
  • Debt default (IBC demand notice)

13. Legal Notice under IBC (Demand Notice)

Applicable Act:

  • Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016

Purpose / Meaning:
Issued by operational creditor to:

  • Demand unpaid operational debt
  • Trigger insolvency process

Mandatory before filing NCLT petition.


14. Legal Notice for Breach of Contract

Applicable Act:

  • Indian Contract Act, 1872

Purpose / Meaning:
Sent for:

  • Non-performance
  • Delay
  • Violation of terms

Quick Summary Table

TypeActPurpose
Civil NoticeCPCDispute settlement
Sec. 80 CPCCPCNotice to Government
Cheque BounceNI ActMandatory payment demand
ConsumerCPA 2019Deficiency in service
DivorceHMA / SMAMatrimonial disputes
PropertyTPAPossession / eviction
EmploymentLabour lawsService disputes
IPIP ActsStop infringement
IBCIBC 2016Debt recovery

Conclusion (One Line)

Legal notice is a formal legal warning and opportunity to resolve disputes before litigation, governed by specific statutes depending on the nature of dispute.